Welcome + Links

Hi everyone, there are only a few hours left until ID-blitz December 2021 begins. If you are tagged in this post, you joined the project in time to become an official participant! Woo-hoo!

Now what? We have a count-down running on the project home page that you can watch to see when the event begins. Once the count-down has reached zero, start identifying! You do not have to do anything special for your IDs to be counted, just do your usual thing or check out the links below.

As you are identifying, if you see an observation that's particularly wow-worthy, you may add it to this project to share it with other participants. Please do not add more than a few observations total to the project--we are not using the project to count IDs so there's no need to add everything you see.

Unknowns

Tomorrow right when the event starts, I will note the total number of unknowns in the iNaturalist database. At the end of the event, we can see how much the total went down!

To ID unknowns, you can use this link here. (It's a bit slow to load, so if you don't see anything right away, be patient.) This link is provided for convenience, but you're welcome to make changes to it or use an entirely different search. For example, if you want to see a particular part of the word, add a place filter after you open the link. I have it showing observations older than Oct 31st to avoid stepping on new uploads. However, I don’t plan to worry about the observation age when noting start/end numbers or participation totals.

Kingdoms

Tomorrow right when the event starts, I will note the total number of observations ranked exactly at kingdom level. At the end of the event, we can compare the new total to the old total. What do you think, will the number go up, because we are putting a lot of coarse IDs on unknowns? Or can we make the number go down?

To make IDs, you can use this link. If you'd like to see one kingdom at a time, type it into the search box after you open the link. You may also add geographic filters or whatever else you like.

Here's another cool link, showing observations at exactly kingdom Plantae that do have at least one lower ID.

Or if you prefer, here are observations exactly at Kingdom Plantae that also have at least one ID of Tracheophyta.

If you'd like help making a custom link, let's talk about it in the comments below.

Collaboration

To pull up observations recently ID’d by other participants, click here. If you have the skill to ID to lower levels, I encourage you to use that link and refine the community taxon as you are able. It will be nice for people sorting unknowns to see some observations get refined quickly. Technically this pulls up all observations ever ID’d by participants, not just those done during the event, but I do have it sorting by recently updated. If you would like to see specific taxa or geographic areas, add those filters after opening the link.

Questions?

If anything is unclear, please ask in the comments below. Thanks everyone and have fun tomorrow!

@abhijatshakya, @annkatrinrose, @antrozousamelia, @arboretum_amy, @avocat, @beetle_mch, @blastcat, @bouteloua, @caja-manga, @calopogon, @dallonweekes, @danieldas, @deboas, @dianastuder, @driftlessroots, @egordon88, @elschongar, @emilyearthquake, @fluffyinca, @fseichter, @fuzzyspider, @glisby, @hederahelix, @helmwige, @ionam, @jbecky, @jmillsand, @jonathan_mack, @kevinfaccenda, @kitbeard, @kristalwatrous, @lappelbaum, @leahmfulton, @lera, @lisa_bennett, @lothlin, @lynnharper, @machi, @marina_gorbunova, @mchs_citizen_science_club, @mmmmbugs, @naturejeanne, @navaneethsinigeorge, @ncb1221, @odonut, @paloma, @peakaytea, @rainhead, @richyfourtytwo, @roysh, @sambiology, @sdjbrown, @sue1001, @teawren, @trh_blue, @trscavo, @valentinamgn, @vireyajacquard, @wildskyflower, @wkostick, @zoe_clark1

Publicado el 09 de diciembre de 2021 a las 03:34 AM por arboretum_amy arboretum_amy

Comentarios

Woohoo! I have my fingers at the ready!

Anotado por lisa_bennett hace mas de 2 años

Go, team, go!

Anotado por dysm hace mas de 2 años

Looking forward to it! And I just realised it starts before I thought it did. For me it is 11am Friday (for some reason I thought it started on Saturday).

Anotado por vireyajacquard hace mas de 2 años

For me it is 1pm on Friday - where are you @vireyajacquard? I’m in New Zealand.

Anotado por lisa_bennett hace mas de 2 años

East coast of Australia. In country Victoria, about 100k west of Melbourne.

Anotado por vireyajacquard hace mas de 2 años

For me it's 4 pm Thursday! That's why the count-down comes in handy. Thanks @beetle_mch for making it

Anotado por arboretum_amy hace mas de 2 años

So handy! I got confused with the starting times of the other ones. Thanks @beetle_mch !

Anotado por lisa_bennett hace mas de 2 años

I'm excited! I had more irl plans pop up this weekend than I expected, but I'll still do my best. Go team!

Anotado por antrozousamelia hace mas de 2 años

I've been getting some practice in already! I have a question about what kind of stuff to add to the project. Do they have to be things we were able to ID, or can they be unknowns that look cool and interesting but have us completely stumped as to even which kingdom they should go into?

Anotado por annkatrinrose hace mas de 2 años

Interesting. Of observations currently stuck at kingdom, 31% of animals, 21% of plants, and 11% of State of Matter Life were placed there by at least one ID from someone in this group! Followed by 9.5% of fungi, 6% of bacteria, 4% of chromista, 3% of archaea, 2% of viruses, and 1% of protozoans. The group with the highest percentage of IDs currently at a rank more specific than kingdom made by someone in this group is Bacteria, at 5%. The lowest % is a statistical tie between fungi and chromista at just 1%, below the group average across all kingdoms of 2.5%. So I think thats a pretty good signal this groups ID tendencies are not distributed at random, and results are likely to be kingdom specific.

My best bet is that Fungi at kingdom will increase and Bacteria at kingdom will decrease, Plants and Animals will depend on how people choose to spend their time and the others all have such small numbers to start with that what happens is fairly stochastic.

Anotado por wildskyflower hace mas de 2 años

I only have an iPhone with access to the app, and the link to unknowns did not load anything in the iPhone browser, Safari.

Anotado por elschongar hace mas de 2 años

Ready to add to the rich store of knowledge that is iNat!

Anotado por lynnharper hace mas de 2 años

I wonder if 61 determined, obsessive, productive, knowledgeable people can reduce the number of Unknowns by 1% in 48 hours. Hmm.

Anotado por lynnharper hace mas de 2 años

@annkatrinrose you don't have to identify the observation to add it to the project.

Anotado por arboretum_amy hace mas de 2 años

@elschongar I'm sorry that link didn't load for you. The good news is that the exact link doesn't matter! Feel free to use a different search.

Anotado por arboretum_amy hace mas de 2 años

I'm excited for this. I love to do IDs, but for this event I got my mom (calopogon) to sign up to help. I'm always encouraging her to use iNaturalist. Maybe after this event she will get hooked. 😄

Anotado por lappelbaum hace mas de 2 años

@lappelbaum maybe we should do a friendly challenge. What say you?

Anotado por calopogon hace mas de 2 años

Thanks, I will stick to what I am familiar with

Anotado por elschongar hace mas de 2 años

IRL plans popped up here too but will do my best to join in!

Anotado por lera hace mas de 2 años

I found an interesting observation but I don’t know how to add it. I have only added my own observations to a project.

Anotado por elschongar hace mas de 2 años

In the web interface on the observation on the right, theres community taxon, then annotations, then projects, click add to project and it should show a menu of things you are a part of

Anotado por wildskyflower hace mas de 2 años

@elschongar you can go to the observation and add it to the projects on the right side by typing in the name of the project. Unless the user has blocked other people from adding their obs to projects they are not in.

Anotado por lappelbaum hace mas de 2 años

Thank you, that worked. Possible Cretan Crown Vetch in Texas.

Anotado por elschongar hace mas de 2 años

Question: I have run into hundreds of duplicates from the same user/date while reviewing unknowns in Denmark. The user in question has been suspended, so they wouldn't be able to react to all the comments already left on these about duplicate, please delete etc. What's the best way to handle this? This seems like something best handled by curators/staff but flagging hundreds of observations would be a major task.

Anotado por annkatrinrose hace mas de 2 años

help @ inaturalist can maybe resolve that @annkatrinrose

Anotado por dianastuder hace mas de 2 años

Thanks! I sent an email - hopefully they can help sort this out.

Anotado por annkatrinrose hace mas de 2 años

Couple of questions.
1) If you are listening to a recording and don't hear anything besides what could be traffic, how do you classify it?
2) there are many unknown observations in my area that are related to some bee project where they take a photo of where the bee used to be. The photos typically have many plants in it and note stuff about bees and whether they collected the bees or not – but there are no bees in the photos. It’s pretty clear they are not posting to ID the plants, or for any ID purposes. How should I handle those?
Here are a couple of examples: https://www.inaturalist.org/observations/identify?per_page=100&iconic_taxa=unknown&order=asc&without_taxon_id=48460&place_id=10
https://www.inaturalist.org/observations/88091090
https://www.inaturalist.org/observations/90552628

Anotado por sue1001 hace mas de 2 años

Or if someone is taking an observation of beautiful soil horizons (which they were). It's not alive...

Anotado por sue1001 hace mas de 2 años

Ugh, I remember there was this project in China where they were photographing buildings that birds had flown into, but the birds were not in the photos :/

Anotado por arboretum_amy hace mas de 2 años

For the soil horizons, in the DQA you can vote "Evidence of organism? No." The bee question is definitely complicated though!

Anotado por arboretum_amy hace mas de 2 años

I add IDs for some of the stuff matching your filter; some I voted 'no evidence of organism', where possible nests were visible I mostly IDd to pterygota. The ones where the caption indicates they heard a bee and the picture is literally just a plant are a weird edge case, I guess it is basically equivalent to a no photos obs that should be casual, so I mostly added 'Life' and voted 'cannot be improved', which will make it casual if someone agrees with 'Life' (actually, if they add any ID and don't vote against 'cannot be improved').

Anotado por wildskyflower hace mas de 2 años

Thank you @wildskyflower!

Anotado por sue1001 hace mas de 2 años

Añade un comentario

Entra o Regístrate para añadir comentarios